On Friday, the actress attended the 2022 iHeartRadio Jingle Ball in a controversial Y2K combo we thought we’d never see again.

Katie coupled a navy strapless top that hit below her hips with a pair of baggy light-wash denim and matching dark blue sneakers.
Perhaps the only clue that the outfit wasn’t a total throwback was the bustier-style detailing on the bodice of her shirt.
Katie’s one accessory was her nose ring, and she wore her brunette waves down with a middle part. Meanwhile, a matte pink lip and shimmery eyeshadow provided the finishing touches to her look.